Pages

Wednesday 8 May 2013

The Question of Succession: Who will succeed Sir Alex?


As Sir Alex Ferguson’s glittering 26-year reign at the helm of Manchester United comes to an end the question on everyone’s lips is who is going to succeed him.

No doubt the United board will have a successor lined up and with Ferguson taking a directorial role, it seems likely that he will have had plenty of input into who this should be.

So who are the candidates, and what can they bring to the table?

Leading the Way

David Moyes

Moyes is the bookies favourite and with growing speculation about his Everton future throughout much of this year it is understandable.

David Moyes
Photo: Mirror.co.uk
Moyes is a manager with a great depth of Premier League experience, as he is currently the third longest serving manager in the division, behind Arsene Wenger and Ferguson himself.

Despite ten trophy-less seasons at Everton, Moyes has succeeded in turning Everton into a regular top ten side, despite suffering financial disadvantages. He has spent wisely in the transfer market and has commanded respect from his players, both reasons he is held in high regard by the Manchester United boardroom.

United will want to ensure that they get this transition right and a manager of longevity and security such as Moyes seems to be the ideal fit. Fans may question his lack of success but given his financial restrictions he has done exceptionally well to stabilise Everton.

The question will be how he copes with the step up to a club challenging for the title and regularly playing in Europe, with no past experience in either matter.

Jose Mourinho

It seems as though ‘the chosen one’ has been pining for the Manchester United job for a while. There were signs that he was eyeing the job in his post-match conference between his current side Real Madrid and United earlier in the season and with Mourinho all but confirmed to be leaving Madrid in the summer, it seems very likely.

Real Madrid v Manchester United: Jose Mourinho insists 'I am not under pressure'
Jose Mourinho
Photo: Reuters
Should Mourinho become manager, he would almost definitely bring the club success as his record speaks for itself, picking up twenty trophies in the last ten seasons. Not only does Mourinho bring a large trophy cabinet, but he also brings an even larger personality, something unquestionably required in order to manage a global corporation such as Manchester United.

However, the question needs to be asked about Mourinho’s long –term credibility. Managing four different clubs in ten years highlights his tendency to become disillusioned with a club and depart sooner rather than later. This goes hand-in-hand with his controversial nature, potentially creating tension within the club, something the board will not want to experience.

If the club are looking at short-term success, it seems an absolute no-brainer that Mourinho is the right man for the job.

Outside Chance

Jurgen Klopp

German Football Manger of the Year for the past two seasons, Jurgen Klopp has burst onto the managerial scene with his recent success at Borussia Dortmund, epitomised by their current place in the Champions League final after beating Mourinho’s  Real Madrid 4-3 on aggregate.

Jurgen Klopp
Photo: ibtimes.co.uk
Klopp has led a fantastic project at Borussia Dortmund where the focus on youth players will not have gone unnoticed by the United. However, with starlet Mario Goetze already on his way to Bayern Munich in the summer and transfer links to most of his other top players, Klopp will certainly reconsider his position should he lose many of his star men.

Klopp’s attractive, attacking style would certainly please the fans however his youth could possibly count against him as United may be looking for a manager with more experience. His relegation in 2007 with Mainz 05 and failure to regain promotion the following season is also likely to count against him.

Whilst Klopp has the potential to excite it seems unlikely that he will abandon his current club, especially during the current success they are experiencing.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer

Few know the Manchester United system better than Ole Gunnar Solskjaer who both played under Sir Alex, and worked alongside him as Reserve Team Manager for two years.

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Photo: metro.co.uk
Since undertaking his first managerial appointment Solskjaer has been largely successful, obtaining two Norwegian First Division titles in two years, showing his prowess as a manager, despite a slow start to this season.
A fan-favourite, many would love to see Solskjaer return to Old Trafford at some point, however it is definitely questionable whether this move would be too early in his managerial career. Solskjaer himself would probably say exactly that, having turned down the chance to become a Norwegian  national team coach in 2010.

It seems inevitable that Solskjaer will have some sort of involvement with Manchester United in the future but it seems unlikely that he will take over as manager at this present time

Best of the Rest

Ryan Giggs – The United  legend recently amassed 1,000 senior competitive appearances and would probably love to move into management. However, with no experience in management it seems unlikely that he will take over.

Frank de Boer – The current Ajax manager has enjoyed success in the Netherlands but many would question whether he has the character or personality to manage such an enormous task.

Laurent Blanc – The former Manchester United defender is currently unemployed but seems a long-shot.

Gary Neville – Yet another former Ferguson protégée, Neville has been linked, but having recently mastered the effects board on Monday Night Football, he will probably want to further his successful career in punditry.

According to the bookies, the battle seems to be between the sensible and secure David Moyes and the charismatic and controversial Jose Mourinho. 

With a statement expected to be released within the next 48 hours, excitement will only build over who will continue Ferguson’s lasting legacy.